Tuesday, November 17, 2026

14th Annual SFA Volleyblog All-SLC Teams

  It is time once again for the Annual SFAVolleyBlog All Conference Teams! A lot of this post is recycled from year to year, but if you take the time to read here, then please make sure you refresh yourself with my methodology and where I tend to align and diverge from the way that the conference creates its official lists.

Continuing the Changes

In 2024 I wrote that I had made decision to dovetail this post into one that mimics the conference structure for the first time. We continued that into 2025 and will do so again here in 2026.

 This is the 16th year (14 in SLC, twice in WAC) I have done this exercise, and I have made repeated arguments for creating actual teams. Typically, I would pick a first, second and third team that each had minimum positional requirements so that, for instance, the "first team" was actually a playable team on the court. I've tried to make justifications for why I thought this was best in the past and I still believe in those arguments. However, over the years I've seen just how many different ways this can be done and how virtually every method has its pros and cons.

 

Similarities and Differences to How the Conference Makes Official Lists

 Let me explain the similarities and differences in my methods and those that you will see that generate the official lists later in the week:

 First, coaches nominate a list of players. I find this totally unnecessary and this is one place where I have chosen continually not to yield. What this means is that the pool of players that can receive official votes is dictated entirely by the coaches themselves. Sorry, coaches... that's too much power and it can occasionally be abused. Here at SFA VolleyBlog, the player universe that we can choose from is all rosters on all teams. To me, I see the coaches nominating players as a MAJOR flaw in their process.

 That's basically the only main difference in how these picks will be made, because now what happens is that the coaches rank players from the submitted nominees and the votes are tallied up. In the past, the top 14 vote getters receive first team honor and the next seven are awarded second team. However, I have heard some talk of this year the league honoring fewer than 21 athletes.  I'm not sure I see the reason for REDUCING the number of players honored, but I guess we'll have to wait and see if the list gets reduced to 18 or something.  A coach cannot vote for their own players. From these votes the top vote getter at freshman, setter, libero, and newcomer are determined and given those special awards. A coach of the year is chosen and of course, the top vote getter overall is the player of the year. Each school submits one list which is meant to be a representation of both that school's coach and sports information director.

 I'll make a 14/7 pair of lists like mentioned above and I'll also throw in a few "just missed" athletes because honoring players is good and I wish that the conference had an "honorable mention" list. Below is a disclaimer section (this is important), my lists, a statistical breakdown of "stat pros" and "stat lows" and then my overall methodology for full transparency. I'm doing away this year with the "stat pros" and "stat lows" section of this post.  That said, anyone who would like to see or discuss the spreadsheet and data I use for this project is more than happy to inquire.  I always have my laptop with me in the gym and love to "talk shop", so I'll happily show you my statistical rankings and such.

As the folks here at SFA can testify, I keep spreadsheets of data on every starting player in the conference on my laptop that I use while I call matches. Those spreadsheets include statistical rankings for every key player in the conference and how they compare to other players at their respective positions.

 

Disclaimer Section!

 (Yes, I need this. My history in the Southland dictates this is necessary) This post was published BEFORE the official All-SLC teams were announced by the conference. I do this independently and DO NOT discuss my picks with coaches or representatives from the institutions beforehand (including SFA!!). Believe it or not, but years ago I got accused once or twice of actually influencing the voters because I would publish the lists before the coaches turned their rankings in. I found that claim absurd but started publishing the list the day or two before the league announced the real winners so that the voting would be over or ending. This list was published right before 5:00 PM on Tuesday, November 16. The schools had to submit their lists at 5:00 PM on that day.

I have called on ESPN+ or on radio a match involving every team in the league, some multiple times. I have personally called and/or watched each team in the league play entire matches multiple times. Based on what I do for a living, statistical analysis weighs HEAVY in making my picks. But I've been calling collegiate volleyball for 13 years now and so the "eyeball" test is in here too. But just know.. numbers/stats are what will always drive me. 

 

2026 SFA VolleyBlog 1st Team All-SLC (14 players)


Calissa Allison, S/RS, UIW [Player of the Year, Setter of the Year]

Kyra McKelvey, RS, Southeastern La.

Julianna Bryant, MB, UTRGV

Jordan Henderson, MB, SFA

Maja Malinowska, OH, Lamar

Ashton Rogers, L, UIW [Libero of the Year]

Martina Franco, OH, UTRGV

Kyanna Creecy, MB, SFA

Lana Rnjak, S, UTRGV [Freshman of the Year]

Nisaan Martinez, RS, Lamar [Newcomer of the Year]

Gabbie Maldonado, RS, McNeese

Ariana Brown, OH, East Texas A&M

Ashley Richardson, S, Southeastern La.

Keira Beverly, MB, Southeastern La.

 

 

2026 SFA VolleyBlog 2nd Team All-SLC (7 players)

 

Olivia Nzioki, MB, Northwestern St.

Avery Koonsen, OH, SFA

Kenna Buchanan, OH, Texas A&M - Corpus Christi

Jade Washington, L, East Texas A&M

Caroline Kahle, OH, SFA

Sophia Tocmo, L, McNeese

Kitana Tuufuli, OH, UIW


 Coach of the Year: Gabby Ording, UIW

 

The following were under consideration for the final spots:  Virginia VanDerWerff, S, Texas A&M - Corpus Chrisi, Katherine Holtman, RS, SFA, Ema Petkovic, RS, UTRGV, Kayla Wilson, RS, McNeese, Gracie Campbell, OH, East Texas A&M, Armie Hall, RS, LSU-New Orleans.

 

Quick Thoughts:

I think it's time to honor the all-around uniqueness and greatness of a player like Calissa Allison.  Check out this stat:  She is 15 total kills away from AVERAGING at triple-double per match.  In 25 matches, she has 235 kills (9.4/match), 585 assists (23.4/match) and 274 digs (11.0/match).  I am well aware that Kyra McElvey could repeat as our player of the year, and she very much has a strong case, but I just can't deny the all around contributions of Allison.  I think the player of the year has to be one of those two, but this year has been weird in lots of respects for lots of teams, so maybe someone else will squeeze in there.

There are a ton of good right side attackers in the Southland this year, but as I got into making these lists, I realized that most of the them had good, not great seasons.  That's why you see a ton of RS's in the "just missed" list.  On Petkovic:  I don't mind if she gets honored.  She might well have been on her way to first team honors and/or player of the year consideration if she had not been hurt.  Then again, she only played in 8 of 16 conference matches.  So, I left her off the lists and again placed her in the "honorable mention" section.

The Newcomer of the Year race is close and I think the league will vote for Maldonado. But, I want RS's to block a little so consider:  Maldonado: 2.99 k/s, 290 k, .294, 35 blocks for .36 b/s.  Martinez: 3.40 k/s, 326 k, .276, 67 blocks for .70 b/s.  You see where I'm going?

Three middles that are good players that the voters will probably prefer that I don't think should make it:  Gracie Brown, MB, Southeastern La., Vanessa Eregie, MB, UIW, Ava Henry, MB, McNeese.

And.. two players that make my list but I still consider quite underrated:  Ariana Brown, OH, East Texas A&M, who technically could also be in the convo for Newcomer despite being a SR, and Kenna Buchanan, OH, Texas A&M- Corpus Christi.  These two are sneaky good.

 

Now, just for fun:  My favorite player to watch THIS YEAR on all the non-SFA teams.  (If I didn't choose the same player as I did in 2025 it doesn't mean I like them any less.  This is just my "loved to watch play" list for THIS YEAR.

Southeastern La.: Kyra McElvey, RS (as always.  I'm in the fan club)

UIW: Ashton Rogers, L (My new "can't stop raving about her" player)

UTRGV: Julianna Bryant, MB, UTRGV (dominant)

McNeese: Megan Grose, S (She pissed me off bad vs. SFA, but hey.. love and hate at the same time, she can dish it, great advanced metrics)

Texas A&M - Corpus Christi: Brooklyn Jae (whoops!), I mean: Kenna Buchanan, OH

Lamar: Katelyn Hughes, S (GREAT hands.  Blew me away in warm-ups)

East Texas A&M: Haley Mullaney, S/RS (so improved...impressive)

Northwestern St: Jade Longlad, S (always liked her)

HCU: Joya Euhus, RS (major step forward in Year 2)

Nicholls: Madison Smith, OH (high error, but finds a way to get 3 k/s all the time!)

LSU-New Oreans: Defne Eciroglu, S (stuck it out in New Orleans and had over 2K career assists)


 

 Finally, Methodology:

 OH: 40% related to kill stats, 25% related to hitting percentage/efficiency, 25% defense stats, 10% serving stats with adjustments made for 6 vs. 3 rotation usage and observation

 RS: 70% offense with half of that related to hitting percentage/efficiency, 30% blocking with slight adjustments made for observation

 MB: 60% blocking metrics, 40% offense with half of that related to hitting percentage/efficiency with slight adjustments made for observation

 S: assist metrics as they relate to 5-1 vs. 6-2 usage, serving, slight consideration of dig/set, significant adjustments for observation, no fixed percentage breakdown like OH, RS, MB. New for this Year: incorporated the advanced metrics from d1volleystats.com that track setting efficiency and efficiency in transition.

 L: dig/set, serving, significant adjustments for observation, no fixed percentage breakdown like OH, RS, MB. New for this Year: Added a bunch of advanced metrics into the mix.  From evollve.net: Dig Hitting %, expected first ball side-out (xFBSO), Reception Hitting % and from d1volleyballstats.com: Passing Rating and Good Pass Percentage.  The "formula" got much more complex this year with all of these new values into the mix.  I feel a lot better about the objective measures for liberos that ever before.

 "Observation" includes all of the following:  notes taken while calling matches, conversations with coaches during year, appearance of leadership and demeanor while on court and on bench while watching/calling matches, decision making, interactions with teammates. All of these things are considered but would not move a particular player up or down more than one or two "slots" within position based on objective statistical measures.